Skip to main content

Telecom Value Chain Analysis

Where value is created, captured, and where it's migrating.

The Traditional Chain​

Spectrum → Infrastructure → Operations → Service → Revenue
   ↓            ↓              ↓           ↓         ↓
Regulators   Towers/Equip   Carriers    MVNOs    Consumers
  (barrier)   (15-20%)      (30-40%)   (10-15%)   (ARPU)

Total intermediary capture: 55-75% of end-user spending never reaches infrastructure.

Stage-by-Stage Analysis​

1. Spectrum (Regulatory Barrier)​

AspectTraditionalDePIN Disruption
AccessLicensed auctions ($B)Unlicensed (WiFi, CBRS)
BarrierRegulatory moatBypassed entirely
PlayersCarriers, governmentsProtocol + community
Value captureBarrier, not marginNo capture needed

DePIN impact: Spectrum barrier is bypassed, not disrupted. Unlicensed bands + CBRS enable permissionless deployment.

2. Infrastructure (15-20% margin)​

AspectTraditionalDePIN Disruption
CapexCarrier billionsCommunity hundreds
DeploymentProfessional crewsIndividual operators
OwnershipCorporate balance sheetToken-based
ReturnsDepreciation + shareholder dividendsToken rewards

Key players:

  • Traditional: American Tower, Crown Castle, Ericsson, Nokia
  • DePIN: Helium hotspot operators, community deployers

Margin migration: From tower company shareholders → individual operators

3. Operations (30-40% EBITDA)​

AspectTraditionalDePIN Disruption
Network managementNOC, techniciansProtocol automation
Billing/settlementMonthly cyclesInstant on-chain
Customer serviceCall centersSelf-service + AI
Fraud preventionManual reviewCryptographic proofs

The EBITDA compression: 30-40% carrier margins exist because coordination is expensive. Protocol automation compresses this to single digits.

Key opportunity: Routing optimization (AI) + settlement automation (blockchain) = margin capture.

4. Service (10-15% margin)​

AspectTraditionalDePIN Disruption
ModelMVNO resells carrierdApp integrates protocol
Margin10-15% after wholesaleHigher with token integration
Value addBundling, brandCrypto rails, DeFi
Customer relationshipMVNO ownsProtocol + app share

The MVNO opportunity:

  • Traditional ARPU: $4-5/month margin
  • Crypto-enhanced ARPU: $15-20 (financial services + connectivity)

5. Revenue (ARPU → Community)​

AspectTraditionalDePIN Disruption
DestinationShareholdersToken holders + operators
DistributionQuarterly dividendsContinuous streaming
GovernanceBoard decisionsToken voting
ReinvestmentCorporate allocationProtocol treasury

The flourishing model: Value circulates back to those who create coverage, not extracted to distant shareholders.

Value Migration Timeline​

StageFromToTimelineStatus
SpectrumRegulatory barrierUnlicensed/CBRSNow🟢 Happening
InfrastructureCarrier capexCommunity DePIN2023-2027🟡 Growing
OperationsCarrier EBITDAProtocol automation2025-2030🟡 Building
ServiceMVNO margindApp integration2024-2028🟡 Emerging
RevenueShareholder extractionCommunity ownership2025+🔴 Early

Margin Capture Opportunity​

Where Value is Trapped​

FrictionTraditional CostDePIN SolutionSavings
Spectrum access$B auction feesUnlicensed bands100%
Tower deployment$150-500K/tower$500 hotspot99%+
NOC operations5-10% of revenueProtocol automation80%+
Billing/settlement2-3% of revenueOn-chain90%+
Customer acquisition$300-500/subToken incentives50%+

Who Captures the Savings​

SavingTraditional BeneficiaryDePIN Beneficiary
InfrastructureTower company shareholdersHotspot operators
OperationsCarrier shareholdersProtocol token holders
SettlementPayment processorsNone (eliminated)
Service marginMVNO shareholdersApp developers + users

Strategic Implications​

For New Entrants​

  1. Don't compete on infrastructure — let community deploy
  2. Capture the AI layer — routing optimization is the moat
  3. Build for communities — those who benefit should own

For Incumbents​

  1. Partner with DePIN — last-mile coverage without capex
  2. Monetize spectrum — wholesale to protocols
  3. Don't fight automation — embrace instant settlement

For Operators​

  1. Deploy where gaps exist — rural + coverage edges
  2. Stack multiple protocols — diversify token exposure
  3. Think long-term — network effects compound

The Flourishing Test​

Traditional telecom extracts value from communities to shareholders. DePIN can reverse this.

QuestionExtractionFlourishing
Who deploys infrastructure?Contractors for carriersCommunity members
Who earns from coverage?ShareholdersOperators
Who governs the network?BoardsToken holders
Where does profit go?DividendsCommunity treasury

The goal: Connectivity that compounds value for communities, not corporations.

Context​